Tuesday, September 13, 2011

Hail jail and bail

Jail and bail are the words of the year 2011. The next in the pecking order might be ‘anti-corruption’ that was in the highest decibel thanks to Ramlila.

It is difficult to find a politician, who was not somniloquous about these words, while they had turned them insomniac. People wanted to see them in the jail and the corrupt chanted the word bail.

Both were the pet words for the top lawyers, for they enjoyed a windfall gain from them. But, the Supreme Court was the show stealer putting the impossible behind bars.

Twice the Supreme Court struck. After managing to get bail from a lower court Ramalinga Raju could not live happily for ever after. He barely spent two days with his family before the apex court cancelled the bail. The cancellation did not come before the Supreme Court asking the Andhra Pradesh High Court to take up the slack before releasing the kite. Its ultimatum to the accused in Satyam case to surrender before trail court came as tempest to wipe out cynicism prevailed. People were complaining the powerful would getaway with their fraud. Raju’s case was the first case to bring smile on their faces after proving them wrong.

The Supreme Court was more scathing on the Mumbai High Court for granting bail to the master tax evader Hasan Ali. Terming the High Court’s judgment erroneous, the Supreme Court bench observed it was "deeply disturbed" over the way the trail court judge conducted the proceedings. Till then dead in the eyes of a common man, the judiciary suddenly turned alive to roll out like juggernaut.

They way the Supreme Court sent A Raja, Kanimzhi, and Suresh Kalmadi to jail was a leson for the lower courts and it made the judges double cautious. As a result, the Kattas, Yeddys, Reddys started falling in line. Remember how Katta Subramnaya Naidu, who was dodging the Lokayukta special court, made a return trip from a foreign country to India to appear before the judge, who threatened to send an arrest warrant, and joined his son en route to Parapapna Agrahara Jail. No bail for him despite spending crores on the lawyers.

Yeddyurappa is also spending crores on his lawyers. He knows, like others knew, that a jail term before getting bail is the only punishment that an accused get at the given situation as the trail goes on for years and the courts take ages to decide on a case. The under trails out on bail can rule the roost, while their court appearance will be as routine as their attendance in their daily work. The media forgets about their cases once they get bail and they enjoy freedom. The glowing examples are Jayalalithaa and Lalu Prasad Yadav. Nobody knows what happened to their cases. We heard the trail is on.

Y Samapangi, Haratalu Halappa, and Renukacharya are now free birds enjoying life. Can you remember these politicians once made headlines in Karnataka when they were booked under criminal charges? Their lawyers got bail for them and they slipped out of the media glare. Who knows whom Sampangi is extorting, whom Halappa is trying to rape, or whom Renukacharya is romancing with?


This is the reason why the Yeddys and Reddys are betting on the lawyers and investing hugely on them. But, the courts are giving run for their money.

The ever-elected representative of Lingayat masses, a man used to think the chief minister chair his own property, is making trips to the court. The Lokayukta court is to decide on B S Yeddyurapap’s bail plea.

The ever-elected representative of Bellary’s toiling masses, a man ignoring even court summonses, is suddenly behind bars. The CBI court in Hyderabad remanded G Janardana Reddy to CBI custody after rejecting his bail application.

The trend is so pertinent that even film stars are facing the heat. See how challenging star Darshan’s heroism was challenged? He is now learning dishum dishum can earn applause only on screen and beating wife in real life will bring a jail term. He is the son of a great actor, who was loved by the audience as a villain. Tugudeepa Srinivas led an austere life and his wife donated her kidney to him. His son is a hero and he could not win his wife’s heart.

The court yet again played a leveler and proved people can still believe in judiciary.


Then, how could Kumaraswamy get bail? He can achieve anything because he is the son of Deve Gowda. And Deve Gowda is Deve Gowda, the real Rajni Kanth.

Sunday, September 11, 2011

Advani said he knew it

L K Advani’s rath is set to roll out for a fresh leg of yatra after a lapse of twenty-one years.

The theme is not temple or Hindutva this time around. It is anti-corruption. The objective is not only to bring back the BJP to power but also to push himself to the prime ministerial candidature, for he is sure the post is no longer reserved for him.

And that is the real hitch.

It starts from the very theme. Anna Hazare might have provided amphitheater for all those who can spiel on anti-corruption, but what Advani has to say to the audience with Yeddys, Reddys, and Modis in to his ranks and files?

He has dared the UPA government to arrest him in the cash-for-vote scam, for he was aware of the sting operation carried out by his party men. He knows no one can arrest him for the crime of knowing the sting operation. But, what about knowing the misdeeds of the Yeddys, Reddys, and Modis, and keeping silent on them? Can he ask for a jail term for himself for this crime?

In fact, it will catch imagination of the audience, if he makes this as the theme of his rath yathra.

Leave alone Bangaru Laxman, who caught in camera while collecting wads of currency notes from deal masters. Advani knew the poor chap was only accepting donations for the party fund. The money collected by his two MPs could have also been converted into the party fund had it not aimed at the stabilization of the UPA government. The sting operation conducted by Tehalka was politically motivated, and the sting operation done by the BJP MPs is done to do a great service to democracy. And Advani knew it better.

He knew B S Yeddyurappa could win elections for his party in Karnataka and he was happy to handover the leadership to him. How jubilant he was when he came down from Delhi to Bangalore to bless the new chief minister, who took oath on the steps of Vidhana Soudha. He knew the Karnataka poster boy could establish the first BJP government in South India only due to money and muscle power of the Reddys, who have despoiled Bellary. So he congratulated the mining lords for inventing ‘operation lotus’ to poach MLAs from the opposition parties. He knew they could have achieved it by spending money like water.

He also knew Sushma Swaraj, his successor as the leader of the opposition in the Loksabha, making annual trip to Bellary on Varamahalakshmi festival to collect ‘lakshmi’, and he knew the Reddys presenting luxury gifts to his party president Nitin Gdakari. But, we don’t know whether he knows about what Janardana Reddy has singed in the CBI custody.

He knew Narendra Modi dodged for seven years without appointing Lokayukta in Gujrath. Still he and his party are the patent holders of Anna Hazare’s ant-corruption manthra.

He knew his son-like Santhosh Hegde sitting in the position of Lokayukta could come handy in getting rid of Yeddyurappa in Karnataka, while there was none in Gujrath. The row over the appointment of the Lokayukta there, and the corruption charges against the state government might help him in getting rid of a contender for the PM post: Modi.

He has to say all this in his rata yatra.

Now consider the question of his prime ministerial candidature. It is a pity that the patriarch, who is credited to have brought the BJP from two seats level to the ruling party status, had to say he had taken the permission of Gadkari for his proposed rath yatra. And what was Gadkaris’ reaction? The BJP president said, “There is no question of the party going under an individual leadership. It is collective leadership we are thinking about.”

Another prime minister in waiting Sushma has bluntly thrown water on Advani’s enthusiasm by saying rath yathra wouldn’t produce a prime minister.

We know Advani knows all this and that is why we are doubtful on the take off of his yatra.

Friday, September 9, 2011

Dance of demonocracy

Anna might have once orchestrated dance of democracy, but who is there to stop an unrelenting dance of demonocracy?

The demons are our speakers and governors conniving with the power-hungry party leaders.

Speaker of the Karnataka legislative assembly K G Bopiah is demonstrating an extreme fairness in case of Sriramulu, who resigned as a BJP legislator last Sunday. He is taking time to decide on the resignation. It is a due diligence to make sure that the Bellary MLA had acted on his own will without anybody’s bad influence, and it was not a hasty decision. A speaker has to do this, in the interest of democracy, because it is a question of an elected representative, while it involves the popular sentiment of the electorate.

So far Bopiah has relieved fourteen MLAs after they resigned. All are from the opposition parties- the Congress and the JD(S) - and he took maximum of fifteen minutes to accept their resignations. The average speed of response was five minutes. It was ‘operation lotus’ launched to poach legislators from the opposition parties adding to the strength of the ruling party. The swiftness was very much required, in the interest of democracy, because it was a question of stability of an elected government, while it involved the popular sentiment of the electorate.

Chief Minister B S Yeddyurappa was fortunate to have a speaker, who knew his business as a guardian of democracy. Bopiah was sensible enough to understand the sensitivities of the ruling faction of a ruling party. Remember how he disqualified sixteen MLAs a few minutes before they could topple the government. His conduct was so saintly on that day that the abuses hurled at him in the house did not fell on his ears. He was so courageous that he did not show a sign of fear even when the floor turned gang war zone between the ruling and the opposition members prompting police entering the house.

Great service he rendered to democracy. He denied voting right of the rebel MLAs by disqualifying them lest they would have pulled down the government doing disservice to democracy.

The Governor H R Bharadwaj is no less a valiant guardian of democracy. He guarded it by denying voting right of these rebels after the Supreme Court reversed Bopiah's decision disqualifying them. He didn’t allow the assembly session to happen till he was overcome by the BJP legislative party resolving to show confidence in Yeddyurappa. Even the Congress frowned on his antics as more loyal than king.

The sixteen MLAs wanted to throw out Yeddyurappa government before Bopiah disqualified them because they were assured of money and power by the JD(S). By the time Supreme Court restored their membership they wanted to support the government because they saw greener pasture in the ruling BJP and promptly came back to Yeddyurappa’s fold. In fact, this was the real dance of democracy. The rock stars were the speaker and the Governor. They rocked at the Rock and Roll party with the rebel legislators ably essaying the role of summersault clowns.

Now that rebel in Sriramulu is vanished with his leader G Janardana Reddy landing in CBI dragnet. He has apparently dropped the idea of launching his own political outfit up against the BJP as leaving the party no longer suits his needs. Protecting his interest is in the interest of the BJP now. And a loyal party man he is, Bopiah is just doing what the party wants him to do.

He could have rejected the resignation had rules permitted. Rules say, a speaker can reject resignation of an MLA if it is reached him through a third party or by post or by fax. Sriramulu, when he had a high, had chased him all the way to Medikeri to handover the resignation letter in person, and Bopiah has no excuse to reject it.

Only way left is: Sriramulu has to withdraw resignation. He is expected to write to the speaker shortly, but there is no guarantee Bopiah returning the resignation letter immediately. He has to wait for the party signal. And the party still doesn’t know what exactly is in its interest.

The dance drama will continue.

Monday, September 5, 2011

Jobs gone, and jobs gone

‘Jobs’ was the obsessive word of August in the US; when the Steve Jobs called it a day, the month recorded no jobs in the market.


The employment report, released on last Friday, shows the economy adding no jobs in August - zero - and the anemic numbers for June and July were revised downward. The unemployment rate is stuck at 9.1 percent, but it would be 16.2 percent if it included the swelling ranks of those who find only part-time work and the millions who have given up looking for jobs that simply do not exist. Alarmingly, the White House said the unemployment rate was expected to stay that high through at least 2012.

While the report leaves no doubt that the United States is in the grip of a severe and worsening jobs crisis, it has lent a sense of urgency to the speech on jobs that President Obama plans to deliver, on Thursday.

Alas, politics in America is no different than that in India. Obama had to address the joint house on Wednesday, but the speaker turned down the request citing a procedural lapse. The fact is that two Republican presidential candidates are scheduled for a debate, on Wednesday, and John Boehner, a loyal Republican he is, didn’t want presidential address overshadowing the performance of his fellow party men.

Didn’t it remind you of our K G Bopiah, who jumped to disqualify 17 legislators in a bid to save Yeddyurappa government? Party blood is thicker than parliament water. Although speaker is the second in the US presidential line of succession, Boehner chose to defy the White House.

While it is unprecedented and shameful, the development reflects on the vulnerability of Obama. Perhaps he is the weakest president in the history. The White House immediately seized on the report to bolster the president's impending call to action. Republicans countered that the numbers were further proof that the stimulus policies of Mr. Obama, whom they quickly dubbed "President Zero," were not working.

The main cause of unemployment now is a lack of consumer demand. Americans -unemployed, underemployed, underwater in their debts, and understandably anxious about the future - are unwilling or unable to spend.

This is worrisome back in India because the parameters in the US are indicating the possible double dip recession. It has already cast shadow on our job market with exports already down sliding is tending to hit further low.

But, the internal situation is not so bleak. The fundamentals are still strong and the markets are doing well with the foreign institutional investors are finding India more safe given the global situation.

It is interesting to note that the consumer spending peaked in India in August, when it was traveling valley side in the US. Indian retailers managed to mop up their highest sales ever in a month as consumers splurged on daily household items, apparels and durables during the Independence Day week sales clubbed with the end-of-season sale discount last month. The spur can not be dismissed attributing to end-of-season sale discounting as the discount was no longer bait with the inflation continuing to be unbridled.

The sluggishness of the US economy and the bullishness showing up in India can prompt the Indian businesses to turn inwards and tap the domestic markets. While it would be better bet for them, the move will help improving supply side dynamics that in turn helpful in containing inflation.


The end of Libya crisis is expected to result in falling of oil prices that would further eases out inflation.

So, it’s time to rejoice, if you are not looking for a job in the US.

Monday, August 29, 2011

Want to be Anna?: dont ask note for vote

Lokpal Bill might not be a magic wand wiping out corruption. The movement for the Bill might be seen as a big scale drama for a small pie. But, it created a strong anti-corruption brand: Anna Hazare. And that is the real gain of the historic groundswell.

The brand and the brand ambassador are one and the same in this case. Hope Anna has realized its importance, while he is embarking upon his next leg of mass movement for electoral reforms.

It is practical to say corruption can not be abolished by law. The menace is so ingrained in the social culture that the Lokpal Bill is a weak brush to scrub it. It is required to convert minds and change the culture. So it is natural to say Anna had to be in connection with people at the ground level perusing them for the awareness against corruption instead of putting up a TV show with fancy characters in T-shirt.

True, he could have traveled, as he has done it earlier, but before doing it one big shout from the roof top was required. And the shout was from Ramlila. It was thunderous and now Anna Hazare is a known factor in the country. More popular than any bollywood superstar, now he can pull crowd wherever he goes.

Before Lokpal movement it would have been impractical to expect an effective social reform from him although he had made name as Gandhian and anti-corruption crusader. His crusade was unknown to the T-shirt activists and the gen-x would have not responded to him as the Gandhi topi was not yet a style statement. For this one reason we must thank TV channels. They successfully launched brand Anna with their non-stop coverage of his fast.

Now, Anna has to tap the potential and channelise the energy. Otherwise the ardor will die down with the euphoric waves subsiding. System will be back to normalcy with bribe givers and takers thriving. If time is spent, Anna has to re-start from the scratch and there is no guarantee of the same response, as it would not be for the first time. People always like an unpredictable drama rather than a re-enactment of older one.

Psychology of the society is that we all think that corruption is something that other people practice. Or it is I-can-do-but-it’s- not- for- others- to- do syndrome. It is deep-rooted in social structure and public life; everyone willingly, or otherwise, consciously, or otherwise, is a participant. The real issue is not this bill or that law. The real issue is: how do we change ourselves?

Anna’s next leg of movement must focus on this. His Ramlila revolution was blamed for keeping dalits, lower strata of society and rural folks out. His whirlwind tour must be inclusive and strictly he must say no to fasting drama and rhetoric of Kiran Bedi brand. When pressure tactics become inseparable from blackmail tactics, they lose their moral strength and become another form of corruption.

Electoral reforms must not be restricted to talk about state funding of polls or recalling representatives or rejecting candidates but to focus on bringing in a holistic change in the system. More importantly, people must be inspired not to get note for vote, especially in rural area. In urban area cynicism is the malice and they must be inspired to come out for voting. The Gandhian way of social reform can definitely change the mind set and bring in electoral reforms.

Then, next step should be whipping in NGOs and corporates. Without cleaning up these two sectors you can’t cleanse corruption.




Friday, August 26, 2011

Anna is not answer to judicial comedy

Had there not been Anna Hazare’s anti-corruption noise the parliament would have created history in fighting corruption this week. Justice Soumithra Sen would have become the first judge to be impeached to be removed on graft charges. It didn’t happen in the Loksabha because of Anna factor. Did it sound ironic?

After the Rajyasabha passed a vote favouring the impeachment of the Kolkata High Court judge, it was the Loksabha's turn on 24 Aug. As it turned out, Anna's fast eclipsed the proceedings and; the Soumitra Sen question will now wait till 5 Sept.

larger irony is that the judiciary, so effective in cracking down on corruption these days, is so corrupt.

2G spectrum scam, CWG scandal couldn't have reached this stage and no big fish would have have been netted but for judicial activism. Ramalinga Raju and Hasan Ali would have been bailed out had the Supreme Court dozed. The CBI court had granted bail to these master swindlers before the apex court intervened to turn it down and rap the investigative agency for its amnestic overtures.

While CEC has become the watch word in Karnataka and illegal mining is taking route of 2G scam, the Supreme Court is seen as an unstoppable juggernaut rolling on to cleanse corruption. The force is so reckoning that people even frowned at the activism bridling the other two pillars of democracy- legislative and executive. No qualms, so long as the delivery is ensured. The BJP corruption in the state is apparently nearing the logical end just because of the judiciary breathing to full life. Otherwise who could have stopped Yeddyurappas, Kumaraswamys, and Kattas?

But, K G Balakrishnans, and P D Dinakarans of the world are from judiciary. As the former shined as the chief justice of India his relatives made the hay in shine and their wealth soured, the latter was a shame as the chief justice of the Karnataka High Court. The day when Dinakaran delivered his controversial judgment allowing mining in the forest area a property was registered in the name of his mother-in-law in picturesque Oooty.


While these two are almost nailed, many corrupt judges are at large. Soumitra Sen’s misconduct is nothing when compared to the scale of fraud they have committed collectively or individually. ‘Contempt of Courts Act’ is the weapon they brandish to scare their adversaries. Even media fears to tread in this scary terrain. The court had brought the media on its knees when reports were published on a group of judges caught in sex scandal, and the news papers in Karnataka had to apologise before the High Court to avert contempt proceedings on them.

When MiDDAY's Delhi edition exposed the then CJI Y K Sabarwal's nepotism, its journalists had to serve a jail term before the case was decided in thier favour. In Bangalore, the tabloid won a contemt case against the son of sitting judge of the High Court. But, these are the rare cases. Corrupt jusdges bully the the world, and that is the norm.


If you are in such a positive frame of mind, you can say judges are not above law and even they will also be netted one or the other day. But, have you got a stick to beat a chatter box sitting on the bench? Indulging hallow talks is the latest trend with the judges. They have crass observation on anything under the sun and there is no restrain. As if they are into rhetoric competition with lawyers in the court room the judges talk too much and their dialoguebaazi is no way related to the case or the judgment. If an outrageous judge suggests closing down a municipal council just because the authorities are not performing well, how should the world react?

The tendency is growing as a menace because the waywardness undermine the very effectiveness of the court.

A chief justice in the Karnataka High Court was notorious for cracking sleazy jokes in the court room. He was insisting on laughing at his jokes otherwise threatening to crack more dirty jokes. If a justice in the court turns a court jester, justice delivery system will be the laughing stock.

Even Anna Hazare’s Jan Lokpal Bill is not a panacea for the malice because it is completely out the reach of this folksy innocent. No hope on Judicial Standards and Accountability Bill panting in cold storage.



Saturday, August 20, 2011

Narayana Murthy: farewell on a different note

It’s the end of an epoch. The cliché goes well with the description of retirement of N R Narayanamurthy as founder chairman of Infosys because his tenure was an era of middleclass dreams taking wings, while his own rags to riches story was the guiding spirit.

Although he holds barely two percent of the share of an IT company with revenues Rs. 27,000 crore, Narayanamurthy is the richest in the eyes of a middleclass man in Bangalore, while he is seen as a creator of India’s first generation of salaried millionaires. Many of his Kannada speaking employees wanted to emulate him mimicked his simple way of leading life by moving to a two-bedroom house even when they were capable of building a bungalow.

Those who were invited to marriage of his children -- the daughter Akshatha married last year and the son Rohan entered the wedlock this year -- were impressed not by pomp but the dignified austerity. The intimate atmosphere was warm with a typical middleclass hospitality not filled with dazzling display of wealth. The newly wedded couple didn’t shake hands with those who wished them, but folded hands seeking their blessings. The guests had a sense of fulfillment by blessing rather than handing them over a formal best wish.

The ambiance was completely Kannada at the Leela Palace (receptions of both the weddings were held at this five star hotel) with poetry of the language being played in instrumental, and the delicacies on menu were with native flavour. Pleasantries exchanged between the guests and the hosts were so natural in the language that people came from places like Hubli and Bijapur felt at home. English was earmarked for those who were from outside.

Muthy’s wife Sudha is a notch up as far as Kannada is concerned. She writes in Kannada and wants to be recognised as a Kannada writer. Her patronage to Kannada Sahitya Parishat is in line with her interests and taste.

Yet, Murthy was opposed when the government chose him to inaugurate Viswa Kannada Sammelana, a world convention on Kannada. His selection was perfect as he was the global face of the brand Karnataka, but he was seen as an opponent in the literary circle because of his indifferent stand on the learning of the language. In their view, he was just a crony capitalist tending to capitalize on English boom uprooting the very culture of the land. He was allowed to deliver the inaugural speech, following a long drawn bargain, but the address was a compromise and miserably failed to strike chords.

While he could have been an icon for the poor aiming high, Murthy is paradoxically seen as a nouveau riche taking potshots at the system encouraging poor to get good education. His admirers frowned at his stand condemning reservation at IIMs and subsidised education for the underprivileged. His concerns over the standards of education coming down by allowing poor to sit next to rich in classrooms were unfounded and completely alienated him from the crowd at the ground level. Paradox is that Murthy is from such a poor background that he got his primary education sitting on the floor under a thatched roof.

People remember Sir M Visweswaraya with gratitude for illuminating their lives without pinching their sentiments and self respect. Illuminating the lives is also in literal meaning because he was the one who brought electricity to the state. His vision shaped the industry, education, commerce, and modern culture of the state. In fact, the brand Bangalore was built at those times and it was a glowing peck on the globe.

Visweswaraya and Narayana Murthy have many similarities in them considering their background, vision, and outlook excepting the former was a great administrator endeared by identifying with the mass, while the latter is a great enterpreneur envied by standing apart from them.

Murthy's name was propped up for the presidential candidature before Prathibha Devi Singh Patil was elected. He was pushed back after he kicking up controversy by allegedly insulting national anthem.

Although, he has said he had no belief in things like second innings, we can expect him to play a long innings differently, while the country needs his visionary ideas. After all he is still 65.

Visweswaraya was conferred Bharatha Ratna. If he can take a leaf from the book of his fellow Kannadiga, Murthy can even be our Bharatha Ratna with or without the crown.