‘Attitude’ is the word haunted his life and career all along. While,
in a relative term, it is good and bad in his own view, the attitude
has made Shoaib Akhtar one of the most controversial figures of the cricket
realm. He is never scared of controversy, but on the other hand
seems to have fascination in introducing himself as ‘Controversially Yours’, so the self-description aptly fits into title of his autobiography.
He says: “Controversies have hovered around me since the day I was
born. Take my name, Shoaib, for instance. In Arabic, it means the one
who brings people together, but it can also mean one who separates.”
He never tried to separate people, as we know from
his life story chronicled in the book of 271 pages. Contrary to his
wish to be a binding factor, he used to be banned from his band.
Suspensions he was punished with -be it from
his classroom when he was a student or be it from the Pakistan national team when he was a star cricketer-were not justified but inevitable in the given situation. The culprit
was his mistaken-attitude of inwardly respecting people without toadying to them.
But, if you really want to pick it up for its title, disappointment is
in store for you for nothing is there in the book
that you don’t know, especially, if you are a cricket follower. The
details about his drug abuse, admission of ball tampering, the way he
came out of the ‘chucker’ stigma and a rape charge, are all much read
about and talked about subjects and the book doesn’t offer anything extra.
His remarks on the Indian greats Sachin Tendulkar and Rahul Dravid had
certainly raised some dust as his terming them ‘not the match winners’
had been taken as blasphemy because one of the targets is none other
than the god of cricket, while the other is the great wall that the
greatest demolishers struggled to find a breach in it. His observation
that Tendulkar was scared of his bowling had definitely incited rage
among the Indian cricket fans, but the controversy element stops at
that and his adulations for the little master shown in the book did
not get the publicity to the extent that the negative coverage the
pitfall could have attracted even before its launch. Perhaps, this
disappointment factor has played the downer and the autobiography of
the supposedly fastest bowler of the world is not a hot cake on the
stands.
Although he is candid in recording his tumbles and fumbles, the hot
hunk disappoints you even on the most important count; he talks about
girls and even mentions Bollywood glam dolls, while spilling beans on love lives of his own and of his team mates, but he never names them.
His rational face gets unveiled when he castigates the hypocrisy of
the Pakistan team management insisting upon the team members doing
namaz in the dressing room. He has not spared Inzamam-Ul- Hak, as the
captain, from ridiculing for his clownish insistence on nammaz that
forced them doing it even on board of flight. But, he does this with
an authority as he is also well-versed in the Islamiath, the essence
of Islam, and he is a great believer. The beginning of his talimaat,
learning, of the Islamiat from a murshid, which continued for fifteen
years, is itself is a poignant episode in the biography. He is so
scholarly that he could interpret the real meaning of namaaz, which is
a far cry for any Pakistan cricketer. You can add this to the duality
of his persona that has otherwise given him a bad boy image.
What really moves you is his response to a few in Pakistan- an
insignificant minority as he puts it- dancing in the streets after
26/11 Mumbai attack. He vents out his angst: “I recall thinking in
horror, people die in Mumbai and you celebrate! Are you human? Don’t
the people of Mumbai have red blood like yours?” His heartburn
over Pakistan players (losing) IPL participation, after the ghastly act, is just an added pain.
While reading an autobiography of a flamboyant cricketer like Shoaib
Akhtar, it is unfair to look for literary value in the book.
But, the narration of Anshu Dogra has done justice with her prose being
a mix of lucidity and banality in patches.
Wednesday, October 26, 2011
Monday, October 24, 2011
Ashok and Advani's amnesia
‘Ulta chor kotwal ko danta’. H R Bhardwaj had to quote this when Yeddyurappa attacked him for sanctioning his prosecution. He had used this adage, then, figuratively to explain his position as the governor dealing with the chief minister facing graft charges. Now, it applies, in literal sense, to the prevailing political scene in Karnataka.
The Lokayukta police have filed FIR to investigate a case and the main accused in the case is their boss: the home minister.
R Ashok, who is accused of de-notifying land illegally, has promised cooperation with the police. If he had real intention to cooperate, he would have stepped down after the FIR is filed. His intention is to getaway with what he has done and the current position helps him in that.
As a home minister, he rules the police department. He can punish a police officer when he feels like doing it. Then the police officer can say: ‘Ulta chor kotwal ko danta.’
The rational behind demanding his resignation is nothing but to avoid this farce. But, Ashok is too brazen to budge. In fact the brazenness is his qualification. But for the brazenness, he couldn’t have become the minister.
When he became the minister for the first time, in 2006, he didn’t know what a department secretary was meant for and had no regards to the process of legislation for he was ignorant of the process. For every media query he encountered with he would say: “We will bring in a new act to address this issue.” When the secretary reminded him of the said act was already in force, he would insult him in public. Somebody had apparently taught him a minister would grow strong if he scolds bureaucrats in front of general public, and he followed it blindly. He was unmindful of the officials making fun of him in the back.
When he was the health minister, the government doctors were crowded at the BBMP with a job of counting garbage vehicles. They were there on deputation to evade service at rural area and Ashok didn’t know how to send them back to their mother departments. He would not listen to the officials as he believed he would be weak in their eyes, if he follows their advice. And the comedy was hilarious.
His public speeches were another act of the comedy play. He could not have pronounced Kannada words properly; his lisping would confuse and the audience would burst into laughter once they get hint of what he was really meant.
Such a man has politically grown up now. He has grown up to such an extent that the corruption charges are filed against him. He is not really dumb when it comes to the land issue. In fact was the one who brought the illegal encroachments to the fore during S M Krishna tenure. Then, he was in the opposition and now, he is in the ruling; the roles have been reversed and he is promptly practising what he learned by observing the ruling party members, while sitting on the opposition bench.
But, the real shocker is from L K Advani, the paragon of virtue. The patriarch, who has embarked upon the rath to cleanse corruption, is fine with Ashok continuing as the minister even after the police filing FIR against him. He had pledged that he would not step into the parliament until Yeddyurappa stepped down as the chief minister, when he was implicated in the Lokayukta on illegal mining. And he saw to it Yeddyurappa resigned.
Why he is not using the weapon on Ashok? We can believe in somebody, if they say it is due to amnesia as the age factor is in Advani’s side. If the amnesia is selective, then it is nothing to do with anybody’s age.
The Lokayukta police have filed FIR to investigate a case and the main accused in the case is their boss: the home minister.
R Ashok, who is accused of de-notifying land illegally, has promised cooperation with the police. If he had real intention to cooperate, he would have stepped down after the FIR is filed. His intention is to getaway with what he has done and the current position helps him in that.
As a home minister, he rules the police department. He can punish a police officer when he feels like doing it. Then the police officer can say: ‘Ulta chor kotwal ko danta.’
The rational behind demanding his resignation is nothing but to avoid this farce. But, Ashok is too brazen to budge. In fact the brazenness is his qualification. But for the brazenness, he couldn’t have become the minister.
When he became the minister for the first time, in 2006, he didn’t know what a department secretary was meant for and had no regards to the process of legislation for he was ignorant of the process. For every media query he encountered with he would say: “We will bring in a new act to address this issue.” When the secretary reminded him of the said act was already in force, he would insult him in public. Somebody had apparently taught him a minister would grow strong if he scolds bureaucrats in front of general public, and he followed it blindly. He was unmindful of the officials making fun of him in the back.
When he was the health minister, the government doctors were crowded at the BBMP with a job of counting garbage vehicles. They were there on deputation to evade service at rural area and Ashok didn’t know how to send them back to their mother departments. He would not listen to the officials as he believed he would be weak in their eyes, if he follows their advice. And the comedy was hilarious.
His public speeches were another act of the comedy play. He could not have pronounced Kannada words properly; his lisping would confuse and the audience would burst into laughter once they get hint of what he was really meant.
Such a man has politically grown up now. He has grown up to such an extent that the corruption charges are filed against him. He is not really dumb when it comes to the land issue. In fact was the one who brought the illegal encroachments to the fore during S M Krishna tenure. Then, he was in the opposition and now, he is in the ruling; the roles have been reversed and he is promptly practising what he learned by observing the ruling party members, while sitting on the opposition bench.
But, the real shocker is from L K Advani, the paragon of virtue. The patriarch, who has embarked upon the rath to cleanse corruption, is fine with Ashok continuing as the minister even after the police filing FIR against him. He had pledged that he would not step into the parliament until Yeddyurappa stepped down as the chief minister, when he was implicated in the Lokayukta on illegal mining. And he saw to it Yeddyurappa resigned.
Why he is not using the weapon on Ashok? We can believe in somebody, if they say it is due to amnesia as the age factor is in Advani’s side. If the amnesia is selective, then it is nothing to do with anybody’s age.
Wednesday, October 12, 2011
Licensing the media and getting rid of weeds
Manmohan Singh is credited for terminating the license raj, when he was finance minister. Ironically, the government is seeking to tighten the licensing norms on news channels, when he is the prime minister.
When de-licensing industries is hailed as a great step towards liberalization that is supposed to have turned around economy, how licensing the media is justified?
Champions of liberalization including Manmohan Singh say, “The government has no business to be in business.” Then, how the government that saw no business in the business sector found a business in media? Not so easy to comprehend. It is as riddled as a live chat happens between an anchor and a reporter about breaking news aired even before its confirmation.
It’s easy to understand that the freedom of press is ensured, if the government stays away from media because it is a simple proposition of democracy. It’s not easy to understand the double-talk of the politicians because it is a complex proposition of demonocracy.
Dayanidhi Maran, now darling of CBI, has a dubious distinction of not issuing a single TV channel license during his tenure as the minister for information and broadcast. He didn’t feel any necessity of new channels, when his brother was running a group of channels sitting on mountains of profit.
He thought market would be cluttered with the entry of all and sundry. He saw a need to check the mushrooms and stonewall the market place. And he did it with dead ease as he had a powerful weapon; authority to issue license. He simply denied license to new entrants. As a result the market remained clean and uncluttered; while his brother, who was already a media mughal, held the fort and went on to expand his empire from media to aviation.
The argument of the present policymakers is nothing different. They are concerned about non-serious players entering to spoil the business. A simple way they found to keep them at bay is to raise their required net worth from Rs.3 crore Rs. 20 crore. Sad, there is no Nobel for such a great invention: net worth is the index of seriousness. The leaders have understood it very well and that is why their net worth is going skywards.
Finding three violations or five violations to cancel the license is another great idea; otherwise how can you control these inglorious bustards? How dare these unbridled TV channels barking and biting and stinging, while the demagogues are planning to step up their net worth to be serious to rule the country? They need to be chained and kicked out, if they found to be mischievous. This is a serious issue and that is why the government is taken it seriously and seriously said it wouldn’t concede to demands of non-serious media.
Indira Gandhi was the first visionary to see this. She did not put up with the nuisance, when her party colleagues were toiling day in and day out to increase their net worth with an honest intention of being serious to be worthy to rule the country. She brought in censorship for the media and the newspapers looked decent under the emergency rule. Now, we can only laud the Congress for having paid tribute to its great leader by bringing in control over vulgar visual media.
In fact, it is better the government expands its horizon to clean and uncluttered the other sectors also. It would be great if an industrialist is made the industry ministry, as in the case of Karnataka. Let a miner handle the ministry of mines and geology. Hand over education portfolio to a medical college owner. A cargo businessman should be the transport minister. They know how to de-clutter the respective markets and how to take out weeds in their respective fields.
When de-licensing industries is hailed as a great step towards liberalization that is supposed to have turned around economy, how licensing the media is justified?
Champions of liberalization including Manmohan Singh say, “The government has no business to be in business.” Then, how the government that saw no business in the business sector found a business in media? Not so easy to comprehend. It is as riddled as a live chat happens between an anchor and a reporter about breaking news aired even before its confirmation.
It’s easy to understand that the freedom of press is ensured, if the government stays away from media because it is a simple proposition of democracy. It’s not easy to understand the double-talk of the politicians because it is a complex proposition of demonocracy.
Dayanidhi Maran, now darling of CBI, has a dubious distinction of not issuing a single TV channel license during his tenure as the minister for information and broadcast. He didn’t feel any necessity of new channels, when his brother was running a group of channels sitting on mountains of profit.
He thought market would be cluttered with the entry of all and sundry. He saw a need to check the mushrooms and stonewall the market place. And he did it with dead ease as he had a powerful weapon; authority to issue license. He simply denied license to new entrants. As a result the market remained clean and uncluttered; while his brother, who was already a media mughal, held the fort and went on to expand his empire from media to aviation.
The argument of the present policymakers is nothing different. They are concerned about non-serious players entering to spoil the business. A simple way they found to keep them at bay is to raise their required net worth from Rs.3 crore Rs. 20 crore. Sad, there is no Nobel for such a great invention: net worth is the index of seriousness. The leaders have understood it very well and that is why their net worth is going skywards.
Finding three violations or five violations to cancel the license is another great idea; otherwise how can you control these inglorious bustards? How dare these unbridled TV channels barking and biting and stinging, while the demagogues are planning to step up their net worth to be serious to rule the country? They need to be chained and kicked out, if they found to be mischievous. This is a serious issue and that is why the government is taken it seriously and seriously said it wouldn’t concede to demands of non-serious media.
Indira Gandhi was the first visionary to see this. She did not put up with the nuisance, when her party colleagues were toiling day in and day out to increase their net worth with an honest intention of being serious to be worthy to rule the country. She brought in censorship for the media and the newspapers looked decent under the emergency rule. Now, we can only laud the Congress for having paid tribute to its great leader by bringing in control over vulgar visual media.
In fact, it is better the government expands its horizon to clean and uncluttered the other sectors also. It would be great if an industrialist is made the industry ministry, as in the case of Karnataka. Let a miner handle the ministry of mines and geology. Hand over education portfolio to a medical college owner. A cargo businessman should be the transport minister. They know how to de-clutter the respective markets and how to take out weeds in their respective fields.
Thursday, October 6, 2011
Steve Jobs, the Baba
In a Rajnikant film, the protagonist turns ‘Rajnikant’ after a visit to the Himalayas. In fact, his conscious goes there to meet a Baba and the hero becomes ‘Baba’. He acquires a magical power taking the potboiler to the dizzy heights of entertainment.
Steve Jobs was the ‘Rajnikant’ of tech world. His words were prophecy to come true. His touch was magical turning dead hardware a lively world of fairy tale. He was a magician.
How could he do that?
We Indians have fascination in believing in miracles. The magician Jobs was born after Steve Paul Jobs came to the Himalayas. He became ‘Baba’ after he met a Baba there. There after Jobs was a great entertainer; business became entertainment and the entertainment reached its dizzy heights under him.
A 19-year old Jobs arrived in India, in 1974, accompanied by his friend Dan Kottke, who later became Apple’s first employee. Soon he had swapped his jeans and T-shirt for dotis as he set out from Delhi for the Himalayas.
While he was searching for Neem Karoli Baba, Jobs chanced upon a mendicant from whom he begged for food. The mendicant was the real Baba. Seeing upon him sitting there devouring, the Baba walked over to JObs and sat down and burst out laughing. The language was not a barrier as the Baba knew how to address a soul. As the conversation continued, he rolled on the ground with laughter.
Then he grabbed the young man by his arm and took him up the mountain trail. Jobs found it little funny, because there were hundreds of Indians who had traveled for thousands of miles to hang out with this guy for some fleeting moments and he had just tumbled in only for some thing to eat and was being dragged up the mountain path by the Baba.
When they got to the top of the mountain, they found a little well and pond, and the next thing Jobs knew was the Baba dunking his head in the water and pulling out a razor from his pocket to start shaving his head. Jobs never quite understood why the bizarre Indian Baba dragged him away from the rest of the crowd and shaved his head atop a mountain peak.
Ours is the land where an atheist Narendra becoming a champion of divinity and religion just by a touch of his master, to conquer the world. For us it is not a wonder the Baba gracing the Jobs to become Jobs.
Then how else an unwanted child, who was given away by his unmarried parents to someone for adoption on account of their inability to raise him as they were just students, could have scaled up such heights? He was the guy never finished college, never went to business school, never worked for anyone else a day in his adult life. So how did he become the visionary who changed every business he touched?
But, attributing the feat to mere miracle is not only doing injustice to the genius but also reflecting on our pettiness unable to reconise the task done. The achievement was not for no reason. David Pogue, in his obit, writes ‘the story of Jobs boils down to this: Don’t go with the flow.’
‘Steve Jobs refused to go with the flow. If he saw something that could be made better, smarter or beautiful, nothing else mattered. Not internal politics, not economic convention, not social grace,’ Pogue says.
We saw a man swimming upstream, against the currents, to show even a lesser breed can reach the heights and it is the miracle of the perfect focus on the target regardless of any distraction. Did he get the focus after his head was shaven in the Himalayas? Let us believe so, because it can make us believe Jobs is ‘our Baba.’
Steve Jobs was the ‘Rajnikant’ of tech world. His words were prophecy to come true. His touch was magical turning dead hardware a lively world of fairy tale. He was a magician.
How could he do that?
We Indians have fascination in believing in miracles. The magician Jobs was born after Steve Paul Jobs came to the Himalayas. He became ‘Baba’ after he met a Baba there. There after Jobs was a great entertainer; business became entertainment and the entertainment reached its dizzy heights under him.
A 19-year old Jobs arrived in India, in 1974, accompanied by his friend Dan Kottke, who later became Apple’s first employee. Soon he had swapped his jeans and T-shirt for dotis as he set out from Delhi for the Himalayas.
While he was searching for Neem Karoli Baba, Jobs chanced upon a mendicant from whom he begged for food. The mendicant was the real Baba. Seeing upon him sitting there devouring, the Baba walked over to JObs and sat down and burst out laughing. The language was not a barrier as the Baba knew how to address a soul. As the conversation continued, he rolled on the ground with laughter.
Then he grabbed the young man by his arm and took him up the mountain trail. Jobs found it little funny, because there were hundreds of Indians who had traveled for thousands of miles to hang out with this guy for some fleeting moments and he had just tumbled in only for some thing to eat and was being dragged up the mountain path by the Baba.
When they got to the top of the mountain, they found a little well and pond, and the next thing Jobs knew was the Baba dunking his head in the water and pulling out a razor from his pocket to start shaving his head. Jobs never quite understood why the bizarre Indian Baba dragged him away from the rest of the crowd and shaved his head atop a mountain peak.
Ours is the land where an atheist Narendra becoming a champion of divinity and religion just by a touch of his master, to conquer the world. For us it is not a wonder the Baba gracing the Jobs to become Jobs.
Then how else an unwanted child, who was given away by his unmarried parents to someone for adoption on account of their inability to raise him as they were just students, could have scaled up such heights? He was the guy never finished college, never went to business school, never worked for anyone else a day in his adult life. So how did he become the visionary who changed every business he touched?
But, attributing the feat to mere miracle is not only doing injustice to the genius but also reflecting on our pettiness unable to reconise the task done. The achievement was not for no reason. David Pogue, in his obit, writes ‘the story of Jobs boils down to this: Don’t go with the flow.’
‘Steve Jobs refused to go with the flow. If he saw something that could be made better, smarter or beautiful, nothing else mattered. Not internal politics, not economic convention, not social grace,’ Pogue says.
We saw a man swimming upstream, against the currents, to show even a lesser breed can reach the heights and it is the miracle of the perfect focus on the target regardless of any distraction. Did he get the focus after his head was shaven in the Himalayas? Let us believe so, because it can make us believe Jobs is ‘our Baba.’
Tuesday, September 27, 2011
Gaft law and ravenous vultures
The graft law implies asset growth of corrupt is inversely proportional to that of the government bodies.
In the last five years, the net worth of one of the sons of H D Deve Gowda went up from some Rs. 10 crore to Rs.500 crore.
A petition admitted in the Lokayukta court said H D Balakrishne Gowda, eldest son of the former prime minister, had amassed wealth disproportionate to known sources of income. When he took VRS as a KAS officer, in 2005, his monthly earnings did not cross Rs.75000. Then how could he become so rich by 2010? Rs.500 crore is just an approximate figure and the petitioner has said it could even be more. The Lokayukta police are probing. Let us wait for the result.
When Balakrishne Gowda took VRS to take charge of the family administration, his younger brother H D Kumarsaswmy took charge of the state administration as the chief minister. The Gowda family prospered under the big brother’s stewardship; each member’s wealth grew to touch the sky. Only NICE man Ashok Kheny knows what the total worth of the family is. Even Deve Gowda can’t tell.
And how did the state fare under the statesmanship of the small brother? Here is a sample. The BBMP attained bankruptcy, in the period. Its reserves that were at Rs. 500 crore, in 2005, came down to nil at the beginning of the current fiscal year.
With its coffers were empty the BBMP delayed its budget presentation by three months and it had to borrow heavily to foot salary bill. Forget about the pending payments for the finished works, there is no money to take up the new projects. Hence you are riding on bumpy roads full of pot holes. The council officially passed a resolution to stall some 1700 works citing shortage of funds.
The BBMP’s budget for last year was ambitious. The estimated size went up from previous year’s Rs.4246 to Rs.8488.54 crore, but it was revised to Rs. 3856 crore at the end. While they could not even reach half of the estimated targets, the abysmal figures were only achieved after market borrowings. The assured amount of Rs.1500 crore as special grant from the state government did not come. The bankruptcy of the BBMP is piggybacking on that of the state.
This year, with a projected outlay of Rs. 9,196 crore, the budget is carrying forward an opening balance of Rs.85.25 crore. Can you find a magician to turn it around? Is there any trickster who can do a work worth Rs.9, 196 crore with Rs. 85.25 crore on hand?
The state government could not extend financial assistance to the BBMP because the finance department did not approve it because there were no funds in the government. After Kumaraswamy took over the chief minister, B S Yeddyurappa took charge of the finance department and he continued as the finance minister till he had to step down as the chief minister facing graft charges, last month. And his good friends Katta Subramanya Naidu and R Ashok were the in-charge of BBMP. Do you want any more reason to explain the bankruptcy?
The change the Karnataka witnessed after it became the gateway for the BJP rule in South India is this: The party that could not even feed lemon rice to its polling agents has grown into a money bag that can spend Rs. 1000 crore to win an assembly polls. A party worker toiled hard to grow from a rice mill accountant to the level of opposition leader could amass such a wealth, after becoming the chief minister that he could build his own republic in Shimoga. And two obnoxious weeds, who divided the city with equal shares to rule it as in-charge ministers, grew into ravenous vultures devouring BBMP and any thing that looked like asset.
One vulture is in jail now, while the other is still at large to guttle the carcass of the dead BBMP.
In the last five years, the net worth of one of the sons of H D Deve Gowda went up from some Rs. 10 crore to Rs.500 crore.
A petition admitted in the Lokayukta court said H D Balakrishne Gowda, eldest son of the former prime minister, had amassed wealth disproportionate to known sources of income. When he took VRS as a KAS officer, in 2005, his monthly earnings did not cross Rs.75000. Then how could he become so rich by 2010? Rs.500 crore is just an approximate figure and the petitioner has said it could even be more. The Lokayukta police are probing. Let us wait for the result.
When Balakrishne Gowda took VRS to take charge of the family administration, his younger brother H D Kumarsaswmy took charge of the state administration as the chief minister. The Gowda family prospered under the big brother’s stewardship; each member’s wealth grew to touch the sky. Only NICE man Ashok Kheny knows what the total worth of the family is. Even Deve Gowda can’t tell.
And how did the state fare under the statesmanship of the small brother? Here is a sample. The BBMP attained bankruptcy, in the period. Its reserves that were at Rs. 500 crore, in 2005, came down to nil at the beginning of the current fiscal year.
With its coffers were empty the BBMP delayed its budget presentation by three months and it had to borrow heavily to foot salary bill. Forget about the pending payments for the finished works, there is no money to take up the new projects. Hence you are riding on bumpy roads full of pot holes. The council officially passed a resolution to stall some 1700 works citing shortage of funds.
The BBMP’s budget for last year was ambitious. The estimated size went up from previous year’s Rs.4246 to Rs.8488.54 crore, but it was revised to Rs. 3856 crore at the end. While they could not even reach half of the estimated targets, the abysmal figures were only achieved after market borrowings. The assured amount of Rs.1500 crore as special grant from the state government did not come. The bankruptcy of the BBMP is piggybacking on that of the state.
This year, with a projected outlay of Rs. 9,196 crore, the budget is carrying forward an opening balance of Rs.85.25 crore. Can you find a magician to turn it around? Is there any trickster who can do a work worth Rs.9, 196 crore with Rs. 85.25 crore on hand?
The state government could not extend financial assistance to the BBMP because the finance department did not approve it because there were no funds in the government. After Kumaraswamy took over the chief minister, B S Yeddyurappa took charge of the finance department and he continued as the finance minister till he had to step down as the chief minister facing graft charges, last month. And his good friends Katta Subramanya Naidu and R Ashok were the in-charge of BBMP. Do you want any more reason to explain the bankruptcy?
The change the Karnataka witnessed after it became the gateway for the BJP rule in South India is this: The party that could not even feed lemon rice to its polling agents has grown into a money bag that can spend Rs. 1000 crore to win an assembly polls. A party worker toiled hard to grow from a rice mill accountant to the level of opposition leader could amass such a wealth, after becoming the chief minister that he could build his own republic in Shimoga. And two obnoxious weeds, who divided the city with equal shares to rule it as in-charge ministers, grew into ravenous vultures devouring BBMP and any thing that looked like asset.
One vulture is in jail now, while the other is still at large to guttle the carcass of the dead BBMP.
Friday, September 23, 2011
Modi medicine for Lokayukta malice
Lokayukta Justice Shivaraj V Patil’s premature exit has thrown up a rather cynical question: do we really need the ombudsman? If a wolf comes in to herd sheep, better avoid the shepherd.
It’s not a question of Patil availing a site from a fraudulent house building society or the illegalities behind it. Nor his resignation can bail him out of his misconduct. The question is how you can bring in a fool-proof system when you are handing over the role of a watchdog to an individual.
When he was the Lokayukta, Santhosh Hegde insisted on suo-motto powers to prosecute anybody including chief minister, while the others were demanding absolute powers for the Lokayukta. We need to thank Shivraj Patil for providing us with a case study for the perils of such powers bestowed on one individual. He had clarified he didn’t want absolute power as the Lokayukta, but his gesture only added to the suspicion that he had come in to safeguard the interest of the ruling party.
His very appointment was ominous with the chief minister Yeddyurappa neck deep into corruption choosing his fellow Lingayat to be the Lokayukta, while the incumbent Santhosh Hegde engineered his fall through his tricky report on illegal mining just before his retirement. So dark was the caste shadow cast on the appointment of Patil that the government brought in a Brahmin R Gururajan as the second Upa-Lokayukta because S B Majjigi, Upa-Loakyukta in place, was a Lingayat and a balance act was called for.
The rot was in the root of the appointment and it took its toll on Patil even before he could complete 47 days in the office, and Vyalaikval House Building Society scam just came his way as an escape route. Smart guy he is, Patil jumped at the opportunity and resigned. Otherwise, his position was awkward; a watchdog assigned to guard the thief and bite the house owner.
Lokayuka Act is a state act and the chief minister is the authority to appoint the ombudsman. Opinion of the chief justice of the High Court and leaders of the legislative houses are just notional with dominant presence of the leader of the ruling party. Did you not hear Chief Justitice Jagadish Singh Kehar cribbing over ignoring him in Patil’s appointment? He said, “Patil’s appointment was government’s unilateral decision. I was not heard.” Who cares?
H D Kumaraswamy, when he was the chief minister, appointed Santhosh Hegde as the Lokayukta and was naturally possessive of him. Hegde broke his heart by calling L K Advani a father figure and took back resignation he had tendered in rage at his behest. Kumaraswamy was further shattered when his name was figured in the report on illegal mining. He didn’t expect it for two reasons; first, he had furnished incriminating documents against BJP and Congress that were vital for the report and second, he thought the report was only meant for cornering Yeddyurappa.
The possessiveness gave rise to a slang match between him and Hegde in public. Kumaraswamy questioned Hegde’s night life and Hegde asked how many wives Kumaraswamy had.
Hegde’s predecessor N Venkatachala was even more dramatic. He used to take camera crew of TV channels with him while trapping corrupt officials. His dialogues for the camera had made reigning silver screen stars dimmer. He was a rock star and people chose him the man on the year, year after year till his retirement. And what did he do at the end? He joined the BJP soon after his retirement, begging for a party ticket to contest assembly polls. The party didn’t find him worth and denied the ticket.
Has the team Anna advocating absolute powers for the Lokpal and Lokayukta for all the states taken note of Karnataka’s example? Hegde is the super star of the team and it should know it from him well.
Anna had no hesitation in seeking Patil’s resignation after he was caught in site scam, but can he approve any one of them in the queue to fill the vacancy? The names of Ravindran, N K Sodi, and S R Bannurmatt are doing rounds. Better not talk about their background now.
Or why doesn’t somebody advise Anna to support Narendra Modi? Modi knows it better and that is why he didn’t bother to appoint any Lokayukta for seven years. Leave Anna alone, an old-fashioned Gandhian. We can bet on the new chief minister D V Sadananda Gowda. He can follow the footstep of Modi; after all, he is the one wants to adopt Modi formula for Karnataka.
It’s not a question of Patil availing a site from a fraudulent house building society or the illegalities behind it. Nor his resignation can bail him out of his misconduct. The question is how you can bring in a fool-proof system when you are handing over the role of a watchdog to an individual.
When he was the Lokayukta, Santhosh Hegde insisted on suo-motto powers to prosecute anybody including chief minister, while the others were demanding absolute powers for the Lokayukta. We need to thank Shivraj Patil for providing us with a case study for the perils of such powers bestowed on one individual. He had clarified he didn’t want absolute power as the Lokayukta, but his gesture only added to the suspicion that he had come in to safeguard the interest of the ruling party.
His very appointment was ominous with the chief minister Yeddyurappa neck deep into corruption choosing his fellow Lingayat to be the Lokayukta, while the incumbent Santhosh Hegde engineered his fall through his tricky report on illegal mining just before his retirement. So dark was the caste shadow cast on the appointment of Patil that the government brought in a Brahmin R Gururajan as the second Upa-Lokayukta because S B Majjigi, Upa-Loakyukta in place, was a Lingayat and a balance act was called for.
The rot was in the root of the appointment and it took its toll on Patil even before he could complete 47 days in the office, and Vyalaikval House Building Society scam just came his way as an escape route. Smart guy he is, Patil jumped at the opportunity and resigned. Otherwise, his position was awkward; a watchdog assigned to guard the thief and bite the house owner.
Lokayuka Act is a state act and the chief minister is the authority to appoint the ombudsman. Opinion of the chief justice of the High Court and leaders of the legislative houses are just notional with dominant presence of the leader of the ruling party. Did you not hear Chief Justitice Jagadish Singh Kehar cribbing over ignoring him in Patil’s appointment? He said, “Patil’s appointment was government’s unilateral decision. I was not heard.” Who cares?
H D Kumaraswamy, when he was the chief minister, appointed Santhosh Hegde as the Lokayukta and was naturally possessive of him. Hegde broke his heart by calling L K Advani a father figure and took back resignation he had tendered in rage at his behest. Kumaraswamy was further shattered when his name was figured in the report on illegal mining. He didn’t expect it for two reasons; first, he had furnished incriminating documents against BJP and Congress that were vital for the report and second, he thought the report was only meant for cornering Yeddyurappa.
The possessiveness gave rise to a slang match between him and Hegde in public. Kumaraswamy questioned Hegde’s night life and Hegde asked how many wives Kumaraswamy had.
Hegde’s predecessor N Venkatachala was even more dramatic. He used to take camera crew of TV channels with him while trapping corrupt officials. His dialogues for the camera had made reigning silver screen stars dimmer. He was a rock star and people chose him the man on the year, year after year till his retirement. And what did he do at the end? He joined the BJP soon after his retirement, begging for a party ticket to contest assembly polls. The party didn’t find him worth and denied the ticket.
Has the team Anna advocating absolute powers for the Lokpal and Lokayukta for all the states taken note of Karnataka’s example? Hegde is the super star of the team and it should know it from him well.
Anna had no hesitation in seeking Patil’s resignation after he was caught in site scam, but can he approve any one of them in the queue to fill the vacancy? The names of Ravindran, N K Sodi, and S R Bannurmatt are doing rounds. Better not talk about their background now.
Or why doesn’t somebody advise Anna to support Narendra Modi? Modi knows it better and that is why he didn’t bother to appoint any Lokayukta for seven years. Leave Anna alone, an old-fashioned Gandhian. We can bet on the new chief minister D V Sadananda Gowda. He can follow the footstep of Modi; after all, he is the one wants to adopt Modi formula for Karnataka.
Saturday, September 17, 2011
Look for battle of brahmacharis
Sushma Swaraj first disowned her political kids from Bellary and then distanced from them. L K Advani resorted to embark on his trade mark rath for another yatra with Anna Hazare’s theme of anti-corruption. Now Naredndra Modi is doing the other part of Anna: fasting.
Methods of these BJP stalwarts are distinctly different, but the target is the one: prime minister kursi. With any one of them is allowed to hit the bull’s eye, as the rule of the game, we see the top leaders scrambling.
As such there is no vacancy at the top. Vacancy can be created if they put concerted efforts to humble UPA in the next general elections that is due for 2014. Then, why is the hurry? The hurry is not to fill the vacancy now, but to be eligible for it. Chair of the prime minister is the final destination; the fight is now for the first step: prime ministerial candidature.
They know concerted effort is required to defeat the UPA. But, each one wants a concerted effort under his or her leadership. This is how the Janatha Parivar failed to overcome the Congress post emergency. Their concerted effort brought them to the power, but the government didn’t last long. Indira Gandhi’s Congress looked inevitable. Now, the Sangh Parivar is doing the Janatha Parivar even before the power is seen in the vicinity. The Congress has a reason to smile, no matter how many scandals dogging the government at the centre.
The enthusiasm is evident in the Congress. It inducted its scion Rahul Gandhi into its central election committee. He will lead the party in the Uttar Pradesh to face the assembly polls and it will be a do or die battle for him to keep his prime ministerial aspirations alive.
The booster dose has come for him from the US. The US Congressional report has predicted that the 2014 parliamentary polls in India would be a face-off between Rahul Gandhi and Narendra Modi. It’s a double booster dose for Modi because it is an indicator that the US that had once denied him a visa for his fundamentalist image is now ready to accept him as the prime minister.
Buoyed by this, Modi Bhai is into complete make over from ‘mouth ka soudagar’ form to messiah of secularism. See how his apology-like public letter reads; It said ‘Indian history is a witness that casteism and communalism have never done any good to society. This is also my own firm conviction.’ If you feel like Modi stealing words from the Congress, it is not your fault. But don’t recall the over used adage ‘devil quoting scripture’ because scriptures are meant for quoting and anybody can quote it.
Another transformation seen in Modi is equally significant. He was known for keeping an arm's distance from the media. His don’t-care attitude towards the media had in fact earned him accolades. But, what did he do on Saturday before launching his three-day fast? He made sure that all news channels were there when he prostrated to his mother, who handed over him a copy of Tulsi Ramayana as a gesture of blessing, and made sure the Muslim participants are seen prominently at the venue of Sadhbhavan Mission.
While there is no apparent resistance for the metamorphosis from any cornrer, Modi’s new gesture is definitely a dampener for the chariot master of the BJP. The patriarch made sure his presence at the venue of fasting to call Modi Bhai “a phenomenon”. Before that, he even blogged : “ Now, American lawmakers and the state deportment are being primed for the return of BJP to power in New Delhi, with Modi at the helm as Prime Minister, following what US analysts say is a ‘precipitous’ decline in the Congress party’s fortunes due to a string of corruption scandals.”
But, his efforts are on in Gujrath to see the BJP government facing embarrassment in the issue of the Lokayukta appointment and corruption cases referred the ombudsman. This was the formula he adopted in Karnataka to get rid of Yeddyurappa. But, he has little chance of success this time around with the RSS backing Modi. He is not even encouraged for his chariot excursion.
Another contender Sushma Swaraj is busy in finding an escape route from the mess that her problem kids have created. As such there is no challenge for Modi within and he is free to take on the Congress.
So you can look for the fight between two bachelors: Narendra Modi and Rahul Gandhi
Methods of these BJP stalwarts are distinctly different, but the target is the one: prime minister kursi. With any one of them is allowed to hit the bull’s eye, as the rule of the game, we see the top leaders scrambling.
As such there is no vacancy at the top. Vacancy can be created if they put concerted efforts to humble UPA in the next general elections that is due for 2014. Then, why is the hurry? The hurry is not to fill the vacancy now, but to be eligible for it. Chair of the prime minister is the final destination; the fight is now for the first step: prime ministerial candidature.
They know concerted effort is required to defeat the UPA. But, each one wants a concerted effort under his or her leadership. This is how the Janatha Parivar failed to overcome the Congress post emergency. Their concerted effort brought them to the power, but the government didn’t last long. Indira Gandhi’s Congress looked inevitable. Now, the Sangh Parivar is doing the Janatha Parivar even before the power is seen in the vicinity. The Congress has a reason to smile, no matter how many scandals dogging the government at the centre.
The enthusiasm is evident in the Congress. It inducted its scion Rahul Gandhi into its central election committee. He will lead the party in the Uttar Pradesh to face the assembly polls and it will be a do or die battle for him to keep his prime ministerial aspirations alive.
The booster dose has come for him from the US. The US Congressional report has predicted that the 2014 parliamentary polls in India would be a face-off between Rahul Gandhi and Narendra Modi. It’s a double booster dose for Modi because it is an indicator that the US that had once denied him a visa for his fundamentalist image is now ready to accept him as the prime minister.
Buoyed by this, Modi Bhai is into complete make over from ‘mouth ka soudagar’ form to messiah of secularism. See how his apology-like public letter reads; It said ‘Indian history is a witness that casteism and communalism have never done any good to society. This is also my own firm conviction.’ If you feel like Modi stealing words from the Congress, it is not your fault. But don’t recall the over used adage ‘devil quoting scripture’ because scriptures are meant for quoting and anybody can quote it.
Another transformation seen in Modi is equally significant. He was known for keeping an arm's distance from the media. His don’t-care attitude towards the media had in fact earned him accolades. But, what did he do on Saturday before launching his three-day fast? He made sure that all news channels were there when he prostrated to his mother, who handed over him a copy of Tulsi Ramayana as a gesture of blessing, and made sure the Muslim participants are seen prominently at the venue of Sadhbhavan Mission.
While there is no apparent resistance for the metamorphosis from any cornrer, Modi’s new gesture is definitely a dampener for the chariot master of the BJP. The patriarch made sure his presence at the venue of fasting to call Modi Bhai “a phenomenon”. Before that, he even blogged : “ Now, American lawmakers and the state deportment are being primed for the return of BJP to power in New Delhi, with Modi at the helm as Prime Minister, following what US analysts say is a ‘precipitous’ decline in the Congress party’s fortunes due to a string of corruption scandals.”
But, his efforts are on in Gujrath to see the BJP government facing embarrassment in the issue of the Lokayukta appointment and corruption cases referred the ombudsman. This was the formula he adopted in Karnataka to get rid of Yeddyurappa. But, he has little chance of success this time around with the RSS backing Modi. He is not even encouraged for his chariot excursion.
Another contender Sushma Swaraj is busy in finding an escape route from the mess that her problem kids have created. As such there is no challenge for Modi within and he is free to take on the Congress.
So you can look for the fight between two bachelors: Narendra Modi and Rahul Gandhi
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)